Why’d EarthBound bomb? Well, critics at the time didn’t help…
Yellow on Metacritic If Metacritic had existed whenEarthBoundlaunched in 1995, the cult-classic RPG would be rocking a 72%. Over atThe Video Game Preservation Dump,Frank Cifaldiscanned every timely review, “to try and figure out why it failed.” Thelast ditch effort marketingmight’ve helped. “The biggest takeaway I get, slapping all these magazines on my desk and reading them back-to-back, is just howcompletely offendedthe critics were by the game’s art direction,” Cifaldi notes. “The ‘infantile graphics’ made VideoGames’ Geoff Higgins ‘want to gag,’ apparently....