Surprised to find out EA DICE’sBattlefield 1943outsold everything else on Xbox LIVE Arcade in 2009? Yeah, me too. Don’t get me wrong, I really love the game — especially now that the multiplayer servers aren’t exploding left and right — but people generally seem to dislike paying $15 for digital-only games.

At least, that’s what they tend to say publicly; maybe their wallets say otherwise. This just goes to show, if your game is substantial enough to warrant a higher price, go for it. Another surprise wasn’t seeingCastle Crashersas the runner-up, but was instead seeingTrials HDat number 3 on the top 20.

Article image

You guys actually bought the game? I’m so proud. Really, I am. For a while there, especially pre-release, I thoughtTrials HDwas going to be overlooked in a big way. For the full list, as well as the 20 biggest Xbox LIVE, original Xbox, Indie, and Games for Windows LIVE games, Major Nelson has you covered.

Hell is Us gameplay reveal

Black Ops 6 Season 5 Multiplayer Ransack Mode

Tekken Tag Tournament 2: a black and white Jin and Heihachi stand back-to-back.

PEAK Bing Bong plushie

Silent Hill f: a woman’s face covered in blossoming but deadly looking flowers.

Mei NERF gun in OW2

Battlefield 6 vehicles combat

Several men standing and watching at an explosion in the distance in Battlefield 6.

BO7 key art